All three are excellent at hydrating my smackers though. My mom gave me a package of Philosophy products for Christmas including the peppermint Kiss Me Very Emollient SPF 20 Lip Balm in red ($12), my friend Kayla introduced me to Smith's Rosebud Salve ($8), and I've used Kiehl's Lip Balm #1 ($7) for years.
I've also got a reserve of drugstore goodies (ChapStick, Carmex, and Lip Smackers) in my makeup drawer. Now that I think of Lip Smackers, has anyone spotted the Girl Scout Cookie Lip Smackers? I'm still waiting for my cookies to arrive.
What's your favorite lip balm?